Combined and Uneven Disaster

 

As we wound down this dossier on Hurricane Sandy and NYC, Typhoon Haiyan/Yolanda struck the Philippines a devastating blow. The still-unfolding tragedy is a stark reminder of the fact that climate change is not experienced evenly. While Hurricane Sandy did billions of dollars of damage to the New York region and has left many struggling, this impact pales in comparison to the scale and extent of human suffering induced in the Philippines.

We are witnessing what might, to appropriate a phrase of Trotsky’s, be called combined and uneven disaster. No disaster is natural, and events like Sandy and Haiyan make it clear that disaster is meted out more and more unequally. In the case of climate change, those least responsible for polluting the atmosphere are, tragically, the most vulnerable to the myriad destructive impacts of global warming.

This image from an article by the Lancet makes this bitter historical fact graphically apparent: CC impactThe upper image illustrates historical greenhouse gas emissions, with global North nations such as the U.S. and U.K. distended to reflect their disproportionate consumption of fossil fuels as they industrialized. The lower image reflects projected mortality rates linked to climate change, with Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia ballooned out to demonstrate how imperiled they are by current trends.

It should also be noted that Typhoon Haiyan/Yolanda struck the Philippines less than a week before the beginning of the latest UN Climate Conference in Warsaw, Poland. Once again, emissaries from the nations of the world have gathered to discuss the fate of the planet and future generations. Previous meetings have done nothing more than establish various forms of green washing.

We can only hope that the devastation of the Philippines will galvanize significant action among the delegates from the global South in opposition to the obstructionism and obfuscation of delegations from countries such as the U.S.

Here is the stirring plea for action delivered earlier today at COP19 by Filippino Climate Chief Yeb Saño:

Related Posts

Not Enough Coverage I should add that there is, of course, lots and lots of media coverage here. Not enough international though. But Democracy Now!, beating mainstream coverage by a mile as usual, is covering the events. Check out their coverage here. It's going on all week. Also, some of the NYC delegation who are m...
Inaugural Ceremony for the Conference We arrive in the stadium of the University of Univalle at 8am, walking through a gauntlet of military police, naval police, army officers, cobra special SWAT troops, etc.  The bleachers are sparsely populated by Bolivians with their union banners hanging off the upper steps.  The main group in the ...
Climate Justice Durban – Arrival Wednesday, November 17 COP17 — the 17th annual Conference of Parties, aka the Conference of Polluters — began on Monday in Durban, South Africa.  The Kyoto Protocol, to which most attendee nations (but not the U.S.) are signatories, is widely acknowledged to be in its death throes. As in previous ...
Andrew Ross Talks "Bird on Fire" at the CUNY Grad Center   An excerpt from Andrew Ross's Bird on Fire talk, delivered at the CUNY Grad Center on October 28, 2011.   Untitled from Social Text on Vimeo.

Ashley Dawson

Ashley Dawson, a professor of English at the Graduate Center/CUNY and the College of Staten Island, is a scholar of postcolonial studies and a climate justice activist. He is the author of two recent books on topics relating to the environmental issues, Extreme Cities: The Peril and Promise of Urban Life in the Age of Climate Change (Verso, 2017) and Extinction: A Radical History (O/R, 2016), as well as many other books on topics relating to migration, global justice, and cultural struggles. He is currently completing a book on energy democracy and just transition entitled The Energy Common.