NYT Readers Respond to Heather Gautney’s Critique of "School Choice"

ST Collective Member Heather Gautney recently published a letter to the editor in The New York Times critiquing the ideology of “choice” that underwrites the privatization of education and “[exacerbates] the problem of ‘apartheid’ schooling.”

newyorktimes-logo_x200
Click here to read the debate.

From her initial letter:

“School choice” does not really involve choice for many American children. It’s a privilege that enables some parents to opt their children out of public schools. These trends pose a no-win ethical dilemma for parents, especially those in big cities: Do we personally invest in our public schools by sending our kids to them, even if that means walking through metal detectors to get to class, coping with high teacher turnover, and having only limited access to academic and extracurricular resources? Or should we provide the best opportunities our privilege can buy, at the expense of things like diversity and social justice that we all claim to value? …

Education is a microcosm of a host of problems linked to social inequality. In the United States, “public” has come to signify the bottom of the barrel. But it should denote our concerted best, what we can achieve when we put our minds — and our wallets — together.

Many readers have submitted responses to the initial letter, and Gautney has since chimeed in with a final note.

Read the thread in its entirely on The New York Times’ website.

 

Related Posts

Old Wounds and New Pain The past can be like an old wound that never heals, especially when the scab keeps being picked. In the wake of Oakland transit cop Johannes Mesherle's recent involuntary manslaughter conviction for the on-duty shooting death of unarmed, 22-year-old Oscar Grant, the injury of his death and so many b...
Class war The Governor of New York State has called for a cut of $53 million to the City University of New York system. This comes after a $68 million cut to CUNY last year, and a 15% tuition hike for CUNY students. This, of course, comes at the same time as a multi-trillion dollar public bailout of the specu...
Orientalist propaganda/image-making by the Mubarak regime Consider the recent violent image making by the Egyptian state in its staging of counterinsurgency terror in mufti. I refer to the charging of Liberation square in Cairo by thugs on horses  and camels, and by vigilantes on foot armed with home made swords.  This is deliberate Orientalist t...
collateral murder If anyone claims that "geek" or hacker politics is x (x usually being some version of libertarianism), I wouldn't buy it. In fact, just like any sphere and arena, geek politics are remarkably varied. Although it certainly includes libertarian politics, there are also fights against intellectual prop...

Heather Gautney