NYT Readers Respond to Heather Gautney’s Critique of "School Choice"

ST Collective Member Heather Gautney recently published a letter to the editor in The New York Times critiquing the ideology of “choice” that underwrites the privatization of education and “[exacerbates] the problem of ‘apartheid’ schooling.”

newyorktimes-logo_x200
Click here to read the debate.

From her initial letter:

“School choice” does not really involve choice for many American children. It’s a privilege that enables some parents to opt their children out of public schools. These trends pose a no-win ethical dilemma for parents, especially those in big cities: Do we personally invest in our public schools by sending our kids to them, even if that means walking through metal detectors to get to class, coping with high teacher turnover, and having only limited access to academic and extracurricular resources? Or should we provide the best opportunities our privilege can buy, at the expense of things like diversity and social justice that we all claim to value? …

Education is a microcosm of a host of problems linked to social inequality. In the United States, “public” has come to signify the bottom of the barrel. But it should denote our concerted best, what we can achieve when we put our minds — and our wallets — together.

Many readers have submitted responses to the initial letter, and Gautney has since chimeed in with a final note.

Read the thread in its entirely on The New York Times’ website.

 

Related Posts

Open Letter to President Obama Dear President Obama, This holiday weekend brought news of the failure of BP's latest strategy for plugging the oil flow in the Gulf of Mexico - the ominously named "top kill."  It now seems increasingly likely that oil will continue to foul the waters of the Gulf until ancillary wells are com...
Time's Up? As world leaders gather in Copenhagen this week to manage climate change from above, activists and demonstrators around the world (such as a human clock in Austria) struggle to hold them accountable from below. Beginning later this week, Social Text will publish a new Periscope series, edited b...
The Generosity of the Archivist A friend of Occupy recently passed away: Michael Nash, head of the Tamiment Library and Robert F. Wagner Labor Archives at NYU. I had only a passing personal acquaintance with Michael, but this is not untypical of the ways we Occupiers interact, and our group thought we should visit his wonderful fa...
2011 Left Forum Don't Take the Bait: The Left and Crisis A Social Text Roundtable with Neferti Tadiar (Barnard), Micki McGee (Fordham), Randy Martin and Michael Ralph (NYU)   The recent financial crisis would seem to present precisely the opportunity that the left has been waiting for: a moment of reckoning when failure is undeniable and injustice unconcealed. Yet crisis — w...

Heather Gautney