The Epstein Class and the University: An Introduction

We had planned this introduction as a dialogue, on the model of the exchange we published in Capacious Journal in September 2018. Re-reading that exchange with these essays now in hand, we find ourselves still circling civility and what one of us has long called, building on Dean Spade’s 2015 term, in the context of the not-unrelated struggle for justice for trans people, an “aesthetics of administrative violence.” We began writing that first dialogue in text messages the morning after the first Trump election; one decade later, and deeper into the authoritarian weeds, we continue to find in that term an apt concept for thinking through the ongoing attack on higher education in general, and on women’s, gender, and sexuality studies in particular.

The phrase “Epstein class” comes from the progressive California legislator Ro Khanna, who has characterized the present right-wing oligarchy in the United States as the Epstein class. Our thesis regarding the Epstein class’s depredations on higher education comes from acclaimed feminist historian Joan Scott, whose 2026 op-ed in The Guardian argued that

“the abolition of gender studies is a way of further guaranteeing impunity to the elite men whose contempt for and exploitation of women and girls apparently knew no bounds, whether they actually slept with the women on offer or simply shared Epstein’s fantasies in order to gain influence or funding.”

Social Text’s Periscope seemed to us the right “middle state publishing” forum for a critical response and signal boost to Scott’s op-ed—here at the start of a new academic year we hope to foster a robust scholarly response to the attempted shutdown of gender studies by the Epstein class and their abettors.

At the heart of this series of essays, which come out soon after the explosion of stories regarding reports of an alleged  gang rape of a Cornell University undergraduate woman at the hands of seven fraternity “brothers,” lies one fundamental question: how does the university and its priorities collude in what Gayle Rubin once aptly named “the traffic in women,” which she defined as a fundamental organization of social ties between cis-heterosexual men that relies on the sexual exchange of women. While anthropologists understood trafficking to be somewhat symbolic, the Epstein horror made it literal, an underground yet private jet-facilitated economy in sexual access to underaged women that surely broke through to the public consciousness in part because the women were white.

Naming the racial politics of the Epstein scandal in no way minimizes the horror of it all, a horror that has unfolded even as the federal government has resentfully and partially released its investigatory files. Our guiding question in this Periscope was to ask: given the appearance of the professorial class and university administrators in the files, what is the place of the university in relation to the Epstein revelations, such that we were even able to read administrators’ emails to a serial perpetrator of sex crimes, in which they asked for advice on how to solicit sexual favors from vulnerable women students? And what ties can we make, following Joan Scott, between current curricular attacks on gender studies programs and the (un)surprising intimacies between Epstein and some members of the university administrative class? One troubling answer might be that in the structure of the university Epstein found an echo of his own imperial designs: the fundamental truth that access to young women has always been a perk of university employment, a perk left untroubled by the university’s weak and flawed institutional structures of redress and reparation. In this, administrative violence extends far beyond the limits of the aesthetic and is materially visited on the bodies of our students. Here we follow behind Jennifer Doyle and Sarah Ahmed‘s crucial work on the fragile and harmful structures that accompany university complaint, in which we as teachers and scholars, as faculty, staff, and administrators, find ourselves enmeshed, at times both complicit and critical.

The essays gathered here converge on a shared refusal. None treats Jeffrey Epstein as an aberration, and none accepts the story that the university was merely his mark. Emily Owens and Jennifer Nash write from inside the disciplinary machinery of an elite institution and argue that the shock accompanying the revelation of university men in Epstein’s orbit measures the success of the university’s own mythology. Their account of Harvard’s decades-long starvation of women’s, gender, and sexuality studies treats that neglect as policy: an institutional hostility that predates the current legislative assault, outstrips it in duration, and cannot be explained by scarcity, since Harvard was an outlier in this even among its wealthiest peers. Grace Kyungwon Hong follows the money from a single faculty correspondence at the University of California, Los Angeles into the structural condition it exemplifies, showing how the presumption that knowledge is intrinsically a public good has become the alibi for privatization, and how, as public funding contracts, administrators come to see the Epstein class as the only theoretically limitless donor pool. Hong declines the consolation of an outside, insisting that all of us are implicated in this political economy, and turns to Survivors + Allies, the student-led research collective whose survivor-centered methodology and legislative traction offer a model of knowledge production accountable to the people it concerns. Greta LaFleur reads the Yale names surfacing in the January 2026 release as breadcrumbs along a decade-long path of university capture, arguing that institutions styling themselves as this moment’s victims are more accurately its handmaidens, colluding in their own capture while trying to duck.

If those arguments ask what the university is, others here ask what our vocabulary for Epstein does. Gillian Harkins returns to her account of virtual pedophilia to track how the term pedophile, across the 1990s and 2010s, consolidated punitive and surveillant responses to youth sexual harm while doing little to prevent it, and how by 2026 the term has become a diagonal instrument: the rare stigma with cross-partisan traction, and for that reason a tactic rather than a strategy, one whose condemnatory force forecloses the analysis that would situate sexual harm within colonialism, capitalism, and care. Harkins finds the university caught between two abolitionisms that mirror one another in method while pointing in opposite directions, one clearing away institutional constraint in the name of extractive technofascism and the other dismantling the same structures toward equitable redistribution. LaFleur presses a related point from the history of sexuality: to name Epstein a pedophile or predator is to obscure how conventional his desires were, and the fever pitch of the response looks less like pushback than like grief for a political horizon now being clawed back. Rinaldo Walcott relocates the scene, reading the private island through Caribbean studies and the plantation archive, with Thomas Thistlewood’s diaries as an urtext to the wished-for black book, and tracking how commerce in flesh, the trope of the tropics as the place where white men lose themselves, and the razing of enslaved workers’ structures at Great St. James bind this story to a much longer one. His turn to Audre Lorde’s last years on St. Croix names something the dossier as a whole is after: alongside the diagnosis of institutional complicity, the insistence that other accounts of these places, and other relations to knowledge, remain available.

We take as axiomatic that intersectional feminism is far more capacious than the parody of “gender ideology” that right-wing educators and administrators are currently weaponizing. Further, we find it incontrovertible that the efforts of students and faculty to further the work of justice, for instance the call to take account of the traffic in women students, is at the heart of the revanchist response to our fields. These axioms return us to administrative violence as a means through which our disciplines and pedagogies, built on sturdy ideals of human freedom and flourishing, continue to be unfairly stymied. The administrative violence presently on view at University of Texas-Austin and elsewhere in the Texas and Florida systems—a revanchist rebuilding of Western civilization by a barely literate cadre of right-wing ideologues who would ruin classical liberal arts study in their ham-fisted efforts to “save” it—is a tactic whose power is by now reduced by its very familiarity. These essays anatomize that violence and consider tools for intellectual response. We hope that they also provide succor to our colleagues in this critical battle for the future of higher education, bearing in sight our students, whose flourishing should always be our main objective.

 

The editors thank Austin Nguyen for his editorial support.

Cover image: Tavia Nyong’o, The Donald J. Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Memorial Reading Room, 2026. 

Tavia Nyong'o

Tavia Nyong’o is William Lampson Professor of American Studies at Yale University and curator of public programs at the Park Avenue Armory. A scholar of performance, race, and aesthetics, he is author of The Amalgamation Waltz: Race, Performance, and the Ruses of Memory (2009), Afro-Fabulations: The Queer Drama of Black Life (2018), and Black Apocalypse: Afrofuturism at the End of the World (2025). He is a member of the Social Text editorial collective.


Kyla Wazana Tompkins

Kyla Wazana Tompkins is professor and chair in the Department of Global Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University at Buffalo. She is the author of Deviant Matter: Ferment, Jelly, Intoxicants, Rot (NYU Press, 2024) which won the Alan Bray Prize for Best Book in Queer Studies and an honorable mention for the René Wellek Prize for best book of the ACLA. Currently a fellow at the National Humanities Center, she is finishing a book based on her 2022 James Beard award-winning essay “On Boba.” Photo: Robert Chang.